Home Forums Patrick Cannon Beneficial Interest

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
  • #447 Reply
    Jupiter Button

    General tax question – but perhaps relevance to SDLT

    Freehold owner of property contracts to sell to a third party. Completion by way of transfer set for 125 years time! Price (lot less than MV) paid soon after exchange.

    Question – what interest passes to buyer? Is it the entire beneficial ownership (when price paid in full) or something less? Jerome v Kelly seems to point towards latter where no specific performance available to buyer. Also – is there a disposal for CGT?

    Do your best Forumites!

    #448 Reply
    Patrick Cannon

    This is an unusual situation with the buyer having paid in full despite the long wait until completion. The basic analysis in Jerome v Kelly applies and assuming that the seller remains entitled to the enjoyment of the land and any rents arising then the beneficial ownership is split mostly in favour of the seller for the time being. It is probably best to look at this as more of a contractual matter in terms of the sale contract rather than in terms of beneficial ownership which tends to obscure the position. Date of disposal is the contract date assuming that this is not a conditional contract.

    #449 Reply
    Jupiter Button

    My thoughts entirely learned counsel.

    Agree that beneficial ownership concept too blunt in this situation, but any lender to first party unlikely to appreciate this! Boxes to tick etc.

    CGT disposal interesting point. Related to above of course. Maybe no disposal if never any transfer, but answer probably in Jerome v Kelly.

    SDLT deemed market value rule also relevant in this scenario, but what is ‘subject matter’ exactly?

    Some interesting issues here – would be good to get a discussion going amongst all you big brains.

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
Reply To: Beneficial Interest
Your information: